 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Oh Me Oh My! What does a judge look for when I enter a Challenge or an Exhibit?
Here you will find some of the rules judges go by, I hope it helps
Critique is from Gladi Alford
This is a critique evaluation form a judge uses on another site, its her own
that she used at the AV show..I find
these most interesting and thought I would pass it on to all you ladies.
Hugs,
KAT
CRITIQUE/EVALUATION FORM
Each doll is evaluated on its own merit and is not compared to other entries
for this Critique. 100 - 90 points = Blue Ribbon, 89 -90 points = Red
Ribbon, 79 - 70 = White
1. EXPRESSIVE IMPACT 20 Possible Points
Strong Visual Impact/Emotion Evoked
2. DESIGN ORIGINALITY 20 Possible Points
Designed own unique form or Creative use of Commercial Pattern
3. INNOVATION 5 Possible Points
Something new and never seen in either form, concept, or technique, or
successfully solved a difficult problem
4. IMAGINATIOn 10 Possible Points
Unusual degree of imagination with regard to portraying the human condition,
a plaything, or cultural object
5. BODY DESIGN AND COSTUMING 15 Possible Points
Neat construction Sewing/Gluing/Attaching
Good Choice of Materials
Interesting/Innovative use of Materials
Appropiate/Effective in Achieving Overall Design Success
Costume Shows Good Color Coordination
Good Scaling of Fabrics and Trims
Costume Well Designed
Costume Fits Well
6. ANATOMY 15 Possible Points
(Choose applicable of following two)
I. ANATOMICAL DESIGN REALISTIC INTENT
Harmonious in ALL Elements
Reflects Believable Human Anatomy Scale and Proportion is Uniform
All Parts Match in Type and Execution
II. ANATOMICAL DESIGN ABSTRACT INTENT
Harmonious in All Elements
Shows Good Consideration of Form
Whole is Balanced and Proportionate
Shows Consideration of Anatomy in Abstract Design
7. PAINTING OR SURFACE FINISH TREATMENT 15 Possible Points
Shows Good Use of Chosen Technique, No Parts Incomplete, or Problems Left
Unresolved.
Shows Good Control of Chosen Medium
I then have a half page blank that is reserved for additional comments.